li: Difference between revisions

Content added Content deleted
m (Add footnote to ku.)
(Merge mi li and sina li into page content.)
Line 5: Line 5:


==Etymology==
==Etymology==
The word {{tp|li}} is derived from the {{w|Esperanto}} third-person singular pronoun ''{{lang|eo|li}}''.<ref>{{cite etym}}</ref>
The word {{tp|li}} is derived from the {{w|Esperanto}} third-person singular pronoun ''{{lang|eo|li}}''.<ref>{{cite etym}}</ref> It functions similarly to the {{w|Tok Pisin}} particle ''{{lang|tpi|i}}'', which introduces the verb except when the subject is the first- or second-person singular pronouns.<ref name="franklin1980"/><ref name="tung2014"/><ref name="verhaar1991"/>


==Function==
==Function==
Line 14: Line 14:
{{Example|kili li moku.|Fruits are food.}}
{{Example|kili li moku.|Fruits are food.}}
{{Example|mi tawa tomo.|I'm going home.}}
{{Example|mi tawa tomo.|I'm going home.}}
{{Example|sina pona lukin.|You're pretty!}}


When the subject is anything other than the words {{tp|mi}} or {{tp|sina}} alone, it is separated by {{tp|li}}, including when they are acting as a [[modifier]] in a noun phrase.
When the subject is anything other than the words {{tp|mi}} or {{tp|sina}} alone, it is followed by {{tp|li}}. This can come about when multiple subjects are used in a single sentence with {{tp|[[en]]}}, or when {{tp|mi}} or {{tp|sina}} either modify or are modified by another word in the subject.


{{Example|sina en mi li lukin e sitelen tawa.|You and I watch a movie.}}
{{Example|sina en mi li lukin e sitelen tawa.|You and I watch a movie.}}
{{Example|moku mi li lon supa.|My food is on the table.}}
{{Example|moku mi li lon supa.|My food is on the table.}}
{{Example|mi tu li kama.|The two of us arrive.}}


===Multiple predicates===
===Multiple predicates===
Line 24: Line 26:


{{Example|ona li kama li tawa.|They come and go.}}
{{Example|ona li kama li tawa.|They come and go.}}
{{Example|soweli li kute e kalama li lukin e kasi.|Animals listen to noises and look at plants.}}


The book {{lipu pu|en}} says that when multiple predicates are applied to {{tp|mi}} or {{tp|sina}}, a new sentence should start.<ref>{{cite pu|56}}</ref>
The book {{lipu pu|en}} says that when multiple predicates are applied to {{tp|mi}} or {{tp|sina}} they should each be their own sentence, instead of repeating {{tp|[[li]]}}.<ref>{{cite pu|56}}</ref>


{{Example|mi toki. mi moku.|I speak and eat.}}
{{Example|mi toki. mi moku.|I speak. I eat.}}


Some speakers use a second {{tp|li}} in this case. This is referred to as "extended {{tp|li}} style" in the {{ku|en}}.<ref>{{cite ku|10}}</ref>
Some speakers use a second {{tp|li}} in this case. This is referred to as "extended {{tp|li}} style" in the {{ku|en}}.<ref>{{cite ku|10}}</ref>


{{Example|mi moku li toki.|I eat and speak.}}
{{Example|mi toki li moku.|I speak and eat.}}


A downside of this method is exemplified in this sentence: it is ambiguous whether {{tp|toki}} is meant to be a predicate or a modifier of {{tp|mi}}.
A downside of this method is exemplified in this sentence: it is ambiguous whether {{tp|toki}} is meant to be a predicate or a modifier of {{tp|mi}}.


{{Example|mi moku li toki.|The food-related me is talking.}}
{{Example|mi toki li moku.|The language-related me is eating.}}


===Edge cases===
===Edge cases===
Line 42: Line 45:
{{Example|mi a wawa.}}
{{Example|mi a wawa.}}
{{Example|mi a li wawa.}}
{{Example|mi a li wawa.}}

==Dropping after {{tp|mi}} and {{tp|sina}}==
{{Needs work|move [[mi li and sina li#Why no li?|{{tp|mi li}} and {{tp|sina li}} § Why no {{tp|li}}?]] to this section|section}}

Learners sometimes wonder why {{tp|li}} gets added for everything else, but not for {{tp|mi}} and {{tp|sina}}. Because the underlying confusion, or curiosity, can have different causes, there are many possible answers.

Etymologically speaking, {{tp|li}} is a third-person marker, derived from Esperanto, and it functions similarly to the {{w|Tok Pisin}} particle ''{{lang|tpi|i}}'', which introduces the verb except when the subject is the first- or second-person singular pronouns.<ref name="franklin1980"/><ref name="tung2014"/><ref name="verhaar1991"/>

It is commonly analysed that there is a "hidden" {{tp|li}} after {{tp|mi}} or {{tp|sina}}.


==Misconceptions==
==Misconceptions==