nasin sitelen kalama: Difference between revisions

Content added Content deleted
(Large refactoring of the page)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{tp title}}
{{tp title}}
{{Needs work|Formatting}}
{{Nonstandard}}
{{SP sidebar}}
{{SP sidebar}}

'''{{tp|nasin sitelen kalama}}''' refers to a common method of writing names in {{tp|[[sitelen pona]]}} which does not rely on spelling out names glyph by glyph. It was created by jan Kumiko of {{tp|kulupu kasi}} as a response to similar, but unmarked systems, which she felt were too unreadable.
'''{{tp|nasin sitelen kalama}}''' is a popular alternative method of writing names in {{tp|[[sitelen pona]]}} based on {{w|Mora (linguistics)|morae}}. It was created by {{tok|jan Pumiko}} of {{tok|kulupu kasi}} as a response to similar, but unmarked systems, which she felt were too unreadable.
[[File:nsk.png|thumb|alt=Screenshot from a discord message in sitelen pona: "toki a. mi pali e nasin sitelen sin. ona la sina ken sitelen pona e kalama pi nimi sina. nasin ni li: sitelen nimi wan la o toki e kalama open taso. kalama [nena] li sama nimi n. sitelen [dot] li lon poka pi sitelen nimi la o toki e kulupu open pi nimi ni. kalama [mu dot] li sama nimi mu. sina pana e sitelen [dot] mute la o toki e kulupu kalama ante. nimi [kalama dot dot] li sama nimi kala. sitelen [colon] li lon poka la o toki e ale nimi. nimi [telo colon] li sama nimi telo. nasin ni la sina ken lili e sitelen kalama sina li ken sona pona e ona. -jan Pumiko"|Original message describing nasin sitelen kalama]]


==Description==
==Description==
[[File:jan Kulumin Sinpin.png|thumb|{{tp|jan Kulumin Sinpin}}, written in {{tp|nasin sitelen kalama}} as {{sp|jan [kulupu <mark>&#xF199C; &#xF199C;</mark> mi <mark>&#xF199C;</mark> nasin] [sinpin <mark>&#xF199D;</mark>]}}]]
[[File:jan Kulumin Sinpin.png|thumb|{{tp|jan Kulumin Sinpin}}, written in {{tp|nasin sitelen kalama}}]]


The system is primarily based on {{w|Mora (linguistics)|morae}}, a unit of speech similar to a {{w|syllable}}. In the [[moraic analysis]] of Toki Pona, a mora is either a vowel (V), a consonant–vowel pair (CV), or the [[coda n|coda {{tp|-n}}]] (N). For example, the word {{tp|anpa}} is split into the morae {{tp|a-n-pa}}.
* This writing system goes with the pu system, where symbols read by their first letter. You can mix these systems!
* A '''mora''' is like a '''syllable''', but ends at the vowel because '''-n''' is a mora! '''na n pa'''
* A word with no punctuation after it represents one phoneme, as in the method used in ''pu''.
* Each dot (<code>·</code>) completes the next mora. ['''<u>a</u>'''<span style="opacity:0.5;">npa</span>] → ['''<u>an</u>'''<span style="opacity:0.5;">pa</span>'''&nbsp;·&nbsp;'''] → ['''<u>anpa</u>&nbsp;·&nbsp;·&nbsp;''']
* Colons (<code>:</code>) add the whole word. ['''<u>k</u>'''<span style="opacity:0.5;">epeken</span>] → ['''<u>ke</u>'''<span style="opacity:0.5;">peken</span>'''&nbsp;·&nbsp;'''] → ['''<u>kepe</u>'''<span style="opacity:0.5;">ken</span>'''&nbsp;·&nbsp;·&nbsp;'''] → ['''<u>kepeke</u>'''<span style="opacity:0.5;">n</span>'''&nbsp;·&nbsp;·&nbsp;·&nbsp;'''] → ['''<u>kepeken</u>&nbsp;:&nbsp;''']
* Everything is equally spaced, dots and colons too!
* Dots can be replaced by similar symbols, and colons can be replaced by the fullwidth slash. Also, these symbols can go underneath the cartouche’s edges in a certain way of writing to save space.


In {{tp|nasin sitelen kalama}}, a word followed by no symbol is read by their first letters, similarly to the system in {{lipu pu}}. Each dot adds another mora. If the word starts in a valid mora (i.e. a single vowel), it indicates the next mora. For example:
===What is a mora?===
{{Main|Moraic analysis}}
In mora-timed languages, there are groups of sounds called morae (plural of “mora”) that are each the same duration.
For example, in Japanese, morae can be V, CV, CyV, N (a nasal sound), or Q (a lengthening of the next consonant), and all of these get pronounced with the same duration.
Most fluent toki pona speakers pronounce toki pona this way{{citation needed|date=2024-02-26}}, where V, CV, and N are morae, meaning that “kon” is pronounced about twice as long as “ko,” and “pan” and “pana” are the same length.


:{|
===Representation of problematic morae===
|-
| {{sp|jan [anpa]}}
| {{tp|jan A}}
|-
| {{sp|jan [anpa ..]}}
| {{tp|jan An}}
|-
| {{sp|jan [anpa .. ..]}}
| {{tp|jan Anpa}}
|}


{{w|Colon (punctuation)|Colons}} indicate the entire word and is equivalent to dots with the number of morae in the word. For example:
====ju, nu, and pe====
It is sometimes assumed that, using only the {{tp|[[nimi pu]]}} and {{tp|[[nimi ku suli]]}}, it is not possible to write {{tp|ju}}, and {{tp|nu}} and {{tp|pe}} can only be written after certain other morae: {{tp|[[anu]]}}, {{tp|kepe}} (from {{tp|[[kepeken]]}}), {{tp|[[lape]]}}, and {{tp|ope}} (from {{tp|[[open]]}}). However, they can be written using individual phonemes, such as {{sp|jan [pilin esun]}} for jan Pe.


:{|
====n====
|-
Many also rely on the [[phonotactic]]ally questionable word {{tp|[[n]]}}, because the moraic {{tp|n}} cannot be taken from the start of any other ([[nja|non-obscure]]) word glyph without also taking the vowel. However, words starting with the non-moraic {{tp|n}} can be used for the purpose, such as {{sp|jan [olin nasa]}} for jan On.
| {{sp|jan [kepeken]}}
| *{{tp|jan K}}
|-
| {{sp|jan [kepeken ::]}}
| {{tp|jan Kepeken}}
|}

In writing, the dots and colons are usually placed in the midline of the text and sometimes with {{w|fullwidth}}.


==History==
==History==


===Attempts at syllabic spellings before the system===
===Previous attempts at syllabic spellings===
Over time, some sitelen pona users began to write their names in more experimental ways. Based on the existing pu way of representing a name by writing a sitelen pona character for each letter in the name inside of a cartouche, these ways veered off into usually using less characters to form the sounds of the name. Among these were:
Over time, some {{tp|sitelen pona}} users began to write their names in more experimental ways. Based on the existing {{tp|pu}} way of representing a name by writing a {{tp|sitelen pona}} character for each letter in the name inside of a cartouche, these ways changed into usually using less characters to write a name. These experimental methods include:

* Preferring a glyph to be used syllabically:

:{|
|-
| {{sp|jan [sitelen sona]}}
| {{tp|jan Siso}}
|-
| {{sp|nimi [insa pan telo]}}
| {{tp|nimi Inpante}}
|}

* Impossible sequences of sounds adding sounds based on what the next sound in the sitelen pona character would be:

:{|
|-
| {{sp|jan [sitelen sona ale]}}
| *{{tp|jan Ssa}} → {{tp|jan Sisa}}
|-
| {{sp|telo [uta anpa]}}
| *{{tp|telo Ua}} → {{tp|telo Uja}}
|}

* Using different forms to the cartouches to indicate a name that is spelled like a word:

:{|
|-
| {{sp|kasi {seli}|font=linja lipamanka}}
| {{tp|kasi Seli}}
|-
| {{sp|nimi {insa pan telo}|font=linja lipamanka}}
| {{tp|nimi Insa Pan Telo}} / {{tp|nimi Insapantelo}}
|}

* Characters get combined to form syllables:

:{|
|-
| {{sp|soweli [kili-awen wile-esun]|font=linja lipamanka}}
| {{tp|soweli Kawe}}
|}


* Preferring a glyph to be used syllabically: {{sp|jan [sitelen sona]}} → jan Siso, {{sp|nimi [insa pan telo]}} → nimi Inpante
* Impossible sequences of sounds adding sounds based on what the next sound in the sitelen pona character would be: {{sp|jan [sitelen sona ale]}} → jan Ssa → jan Sisa, {{sp|telo [uta anpa]}} → telo Ua → telo Uja, {{sp|nimi [insa pan ale]}} → nimi Ipa
* Using different forms to the cartouches to signify a name that is spelled like a word: {{sp|kasi {seli<nowiki>}</nowiki>}} → kasi Seli, {{sp|nimi {insa pan telo<nowiki>}</nowiki>}} → nimi Insa Pan Telo (or nimi Insapantelo)
* Characters get combined to form syllables: {{sp|soweli [kili-awen wile-esun]}} → soweli Kawe
None of these were solidified and virtually all of them were met with confusion by others for a number of reasons. For example, forming cartouches differently is just something that happens in handwriting and isn't really enough to mark the cartouche as having a different system; unmarked systems are largely backwards-incompatible with pu spelling and it's not clear if [insa pan ale] spells out Ipa or Inpana or Insapanale or anything in-between; unexpectedly encountering another system stops reading flow and requires nice knowledge; no one can agree on using the same system
None of these were solidified and virtually all of them were met with confusion by others for a number of reasons. For example, forming cartouches differently is just something that happens in handwriting and isn't really enough to mark the cartouche as having a different system; unmarked systems are largely backwards-incompatible with pu spelling and it's not clear if [insa pan ale] spells out Ipa or Inpana or Insapanale or anything in-between; unexpectedly encountering another system stops reading flow and requires nice knowledge; no one can agree on using the same system


===Creation of {{tp|nasin sitelen kalama}}===
===Creation of {{tp|nasin sitelen kalama}}===
[[File:nsk.png|250px|thumb|alt=Screenshot from a discord message in sitelen pona: "toki a. mi pali e nasin sitelen sin. ona la sina ken sitelen pona e kalama pi nimi sina. nasin ni li: sitelen nimi wan la o toki e kalama open taso. kalama [nena] li sama nimi n. sitelen [dot] li lon poka pi sitelen nimi la o toki e kulupu open pi nimi ni. kalama [mu dot] li sama nimi mu. sina pana e sitelen [dot] mute la o toki e kulupu kalama ante. nimi [kalama dot dot] li sama nimi kala. sitelen [colon] li lon poka la o toki e ale nimi. nimi [telo colon] li sama nimi telo. nasin ni la sina ken lili e sitelen kalama sina li ken sona pona e ona. -jan Pumiko"|Original message describing nasin sitelen kalama]]
{{Empty}}

{{tp|nasin sitelen kalama}} was created by {{tok|jan Pumiko}}, a member of the {{tok|kulupu kasi}} system, in 2022. This was in order to formalize the previous systems.


===Adoption===
===Adoption===
{{Needs work|scope=section}}

In an informal emoji reactions poll on the Discord server ma pona pi toki pona<ref>[https://discord.com/channels/301377942062366741/828474497865744444/1067795425278562334 link to poll], data from 2023-01-30; 72 responses, of these, 62 reported being able to read sp and 54 reported writing in sitelen pona</ref>, 77.4% of those who can read sitelen pona and 81.5% of those who write in sitelen pona can read nasin sitelen kalama. 54.8% of sp readers and 61.1% of sp writers use it.
In an informal emoji reactions poll on the Discord server ma pona pi toki pona<ref>[https://discord.com/channels/301377942062366741/828474497865744444/1067795425278562334 link to poll], data from 2023-01-30; 72 responses, of these, 62 reported being able to read sp and 54 reported writing in sitelen pona</ref>, 77.4% of those who can read sitelen pona and 81.5% of those who write in sitelen pona can read nasin sitelen kalama. 54.8% of sp readers and 61.1% of sp writers use it.


==Applications==
==Applications==
[[File:Kijetesantakalu sewi (sitelen pona) - chorus.png|250px|thumb|{{tp|nasin sitelen kalama}} used to indicate morae in the sheet music for {{tp|kijetesantakalu sewi}}]]
{{Needs work|Add images instead of formatting|section}}


{{tp|nasin sitelen kalama}} can be used to write {{tp|sitelen pona}} lyrics in [[sheet music]]. For example, <big style="font-size:2em;">{{ruby|position=under|&nbsp;♩&nbsp;|{{tp|ke}}|&nbsp;♩&nbsp;|{{tp|pe}}|&nbsp;♩&nbsp;|{{tp|ken}}}}</big> can be written as <big style="font-size:2em;">{{ruby|position=under|&nbsp;♩&nbsp;|<small><small>{{sps|kepeken}}</small></small>'''·'''|&nbsp;♩&nbsp;|'''·'''|&nbsp;♩&nbsp;|'''··'''}}</big>.
{{tp|nasin sitelen kalama}} can be used to write {{tp|sitelen pona}} lyrics in [[sheet music]].


==Criticism and limitations==
==Criticism and limitations==
{{Needs work|scope=section}}
* small dots are too easy to mistake for "lili"
* small dots are too easy to mistake for "lili"
* people use it as if it were the new default system, but it's only meant to formalise a way for the people who would otherwise use much worse systems, not to replace or officially expand the sitelen pona cartouches
* people use it as if it were the new default system, but it's only meant to formalise a way for the people who would otherwise use much worse systems, not to replace or officially expand the sitelen pona cartouches
*Cartouches may be [[ambiguous]] on the rare, but feasible, occasion that multiple words share a glyph. Examples include {{spt|[󱤄󱦝]}} representing {{tp|Ale}} or {{tp|Ali}}, and, less standardly, the case of [[abbreviation]]s with different pronunciations but unchanged glyphs.
*Cartouches may be [[ambiguous]] on the rare, but feasible, occasion that multiple words share a glyph. Examples include {{spt|[ale ::]}} representing {{tp|Ale}} or {{tp|Ali}}, and, less standardly, the case of [[abbreviation]]s with different pronunciations but unchanged glyphs.


==References==
==References==