sona pona:Notability: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
mNo edit summary
No edit summary
 
(6 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{Wiki essay}}
{{Shortcut|SP:N}}
'''Notability''' is a measure of whether a topic warrants its own article, or mention on the wiki in general. Since Toki Pona is a niche topic in itself, the notability standards for {{tp|sona pona}} are more permissive than {{w|ProjectWP:NotabilityN|those for Wikipedia}}; topics are judged by their relevance to the language or [[community]] culture.
 
Editors have varying opinions on what the wiki should include. {{w|Deletionist}}s are often concerned with learners absorbing [[word]]s and [[styles of speech]] that are not widely used or understood in practice, by which {{tp|sona pona}} would artificially influence the language rather than covering it responsibly. {{w|Inclusionist}}s have argued that within Toki Pona, presence in a [[learning resource]] or [[font]] may amount to notability, and {{tp|sona pona}} coverage could provide better usage disclaimers, nuance, and citations than other resources.
 
==Standards==
Current standards include:
* Features that are not in standard use may still be notable—of historical significance, memetic in the community, circulated through many completionist resources, etc.—but must be marked and described as nonstandard. They should also explain what the standard style does instead and why.
* Additions to existing systems require a higher level of notability than new systems.
* Articles should not give {{w|ProjectWP:Undue weightUNDUE|undue weight}} to significantly less notable topics. For example, see {{sect|Project:Word articles#Related words}}.
* A list may warrant its own article, even if not all of its items do, and even if the list does not form a coherent style of Toki Pona usage.
* [[mw:Help:User page|User pages]] are not subject to notability requirements.
Line 14 ⟶ 15:
==Word articles==
{{Main|Project:Word articles}}
{{Needs work|scope=section}}
 
===Glyphs===
{{Hatnote|See also [[:Category:Words with sitelen pona glyphs detected in sitelen seli kiwen]].}}
There is little data on usage of {{tp|[[sitelen pona]]}} and {{tp|[[sitelen sitelen]]}} glyphs in the community. Many are <em>proposed</em> by [[font]]makers or other [[Tokiponist]]s for {{wikt|completionism|completionist}} purposes, but see little to no <em>usage</em> in practice.
 
On the one hand, these glyphs should not be given undue weight. On the other, readers may already be disproportionately familiar with them from font repertoires, dictionaries (such as {{tok|[[Linku]]}}), and even personal experimentation with fonts. They could easily assume that such a glyph is in common usage, and that the wiki article is merely incomplete if the glyph is absent.
 
The current consensus is that these sorts of nonstandard and proposed glyphs may be included, but: they should not be described as "the" glyph for a certain word, nor displayed in the infobox. A suggested exception is if a glyph was designed by the word's coiner, demonstrating that the word is intended to be associated with that glyph.
* They should not be described as "{{wikt|the}}" glyph for a certain word.
* As such, they should not show up in the infobox. (This may happen automatically; an in-template solution is to be developed.)
 
HereBelow is an example {{tp|sitelen pona}} section to fill in for a [[historical]] word. Forwith othera cases,nonstandard glyph. Replace the first<code>{{w|HTML sentencecomment|<nowiki><!--</nowiki>comments<nowiki>--></nowiki>}}</code> canwith the beappropriate tweakedtext.
 
<syntaxhighlight lang="html+handlebarswikitext">
==={{tp|sitelen pona}}===
[[File:Sitelen seli kiwen - {{subst:PAGENAME}}.png|thumb|60px|{{tp|{{subst:PAGENAME}}}} in {{tp|[[sitelen seli kiwen]]}}]]
The word {{tp|{{subst:PAGENAME}}}} <!--predated/is not often used in--> {{tp|[[sitelen pona]]}};. aA proposed glyph ({{sp|{{subst:PAGENAME}}}}) was later proposeddesigned by <!--whom?--> in <!--when?-->, so that it could be used in the writing system<!--why?-->. The proposed glyph ({{sp|{{subst:PAGENAME}}}}) isIt <!--depicts/represents/is derived from/is composed of <!--…of…-->. In practice, it is unknown whether thethis glyph sees significant use.
</syntaxhighlight>
{{Project}}